Company management systems models evaluation

   In order to form all elements of company management, it is necessary to choose the right management model that fully corresponds to the peculiarities of the sphere of existence, the personnel’s needs and the activity goals.

   The purpose of the study is to examine the management systems existing models and evaluate them with regard to their use in Russian companies.

   Within the framework of the work, theoretical and empirical methods were used to analyze the existing management experience. Studies of Russian and foreign specialists in the field of evaluation of management systems existing models and their effectiveness have been studied. In the course of the work it has been revealed that each of the existing national management systems was formed over many years, based on the peculiarities of the employees’ mentality and the market specifics. The American and European systems are more focused on obtaining economic results (profit), and the Japanese and Arab systems are more focused on meeting the needs of society and their employees. Each of them is to a certain extent effective within the framework of its state, but their application in other countries requires considerable adaptation. In recent years, several new management models have been developed that are able to adapt to environmental changes and are aimed at high performance. In Russian companies, modern models may be the most effective (marketing, “full” or integration models), but it is necessary to develop their own management systems to ensure high efficiency.

1. Weinberg, R. B., Mathis, R. L., Weinberg R.B., Mathis R.L., Cherrington D.C. Human Resource Certification Institute Certification Study Guide. Alexandria, VA: Human Resource Certification Institute; 1991. 142 p.

2. Peregudova S.A., Agafonova M.S. Features of the American model of management. Modern knowledge-intensive technologies. 2014;7-2:134. (In Russian).

3. Korshunov A.A. Comparative analysis of American and Japanese models of human resource management, their impact on the domestic model of personnel management. Stolypinskii vestnik. 2021;5(3). (In Russian).

4. Pashayeva Z.S., Vartanova D.S. Personnel management in the Japanese model of management. In: Dzagoev S.F. (ed.) Management of regional economic and social systems. Vladikavkaz: North Ossetian State University after K.L. Khetagurov; 2015. Pp. 186–191. (In Russian).

5. Kochergina A.A. Analysis of Japanese system of management in the context of its use by Russian companies. SCI-ARTICLE.RU. 2015;27. (In Russian).

6. Chudnovskaya S.N. European model of management. In: Chudnovskaya S.N. History of management. Moscow: Yurait; 2017. Pp. 171–185. (In Russian).

7. Pirogov A.I., Svechnikov N.S. Comparative Analysis of Contemporary Business Management Models. Economical and Social-Humanitarian Research. 2018;3(19):47–56. (In Russian). URL: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/sravnitelnyy-analiz-sovremennyh-modeley-upravleniya-predpriyatiem?ysclid=lzwnn3qydu168224967

8. Igumnov D. Characteristic features of the European management model. Samoupravlenie. 2018;S1:76–78. (In Russian).

9. Shirinkina E.V. Business models in the conditions of increasing complexity of the business environment. Journal of Volgograd State University: Economics. 2021;1:121–130. (In Russian). doi: 10.15688/ek.jvolsu.2021.1.10

10. Mitrofanov D.E., Onuchina A.A., Shpak E.V. et al. Analysis of corporate governance foreign models and their application in Russian practice. In: Economic science and practice: Proceedings of the VI International Scientific Conference, Chita, April 20–23, 2018. Chita: Molodoi uchenyi; 2018. Pp. 32–34. (In Russian).

11. Ermakova M.Yu., Chekalin V.S. Comparative analysis of management models of engineering and energy complex enterprises in large city. In: Fedoseev I.V. (ed.) Theory and Practice of Management of State Functions and Services. Tariff regulation: Proceedings of the III National Scientific and Practical Conference, St. Petersburg, November 10, 2020. St. Petersburg: St. Petersburg State University of Economics; 2020. Pp. 95–100. (In Russian).

12. Zhemchugov A.M., Zhemchugov M.K. Full model of organization management. Management Today. 2017;2(98):116–133. (In Russian).

13. Gafforova E.B. Way to resolve contradictions – unified enterprise management system based on quality. Standards and Quality. 2006;10:74–77. (In Russian).

14. Merkushova N.I., Gafforova E.B., Merkushova Yu.A. On the question of choosing a model of organization management system when using international standards in the field of management. Molodoi uchenyi. 2013;11(58):398–404. (In Russian).

15. Porshakov S., Gilbert K., Ivakhnik A. Results of the survey conducted by the National Council on Corporate Governance. Modern corporate governance in Russia through the eyes of foreign businessmen and experts. 2016;3:4–8. (In Russian).

16. Mallin C. International corporative governance: a case study approach. Northampton, Massachusetts, USA: Edward Eldar Publishing Ltd.; 2016. 247 p.

17. Dignam A., Galanis M. The globalization of corporate governance. Farnham, UK: Ashgate Publishing; 2015. 188 p.