Methods for assessing management systems effectiveness

Management systems effectiveness analysis today is of great importance, as the conditions of the external environment are changing rapidly, which means that effective management systems must meet the challenges of the time. At the same time, it represents a certain complexity, since it involves the quan titative and qualitative indicators analysis. For this reason, there are practical ly no comprehensive assessment methods developed in the scientific world. Each method has its advantages and disadvantages, so researchers recommend the simultaneous use of several methods to assess the effectiveness of man agement system functioning from different aspects of its activities. Howev er, it is also quite problematic and requires several experts involvement who will make the assessment. A comprehensive analysis of scientific sources re vealing the essence of management systems, the management system effec tiveness concepts, as well as the main methods of evaluation has been car ried out. The author’s attempt to clarify the methodological apparatus based on the findings has been made. As the analysis result, the methodological ap paratus necessary to ensure the process of assessing management systems ef fectiveness has been clarified. The obtained conclusions made it possible to de velop the author’s method of assessing management systems effectiveness, which allows to assess both quantitative and qualitative performance indicators.

1. Trinh Dinh Cong. Forming and developing knowledge management system in an oil and gas company. Abstr. ... Cand. Sci. (Econ.): 5.2.6. St. Petersburg: St. Petersburg Mining University; 2021. 20 p. (In Russian).

2. Staroverova K.O. Management. Efficiency of management. 2nd ed., revised and enlarged Moscow: Yurait; 2019. 269 p. (In Rus sian).

3. Meskon M., Albert M., Hedouri F. Fundamentals of management. Moscow: Williams; 2017. 672 p. (In Russian).

4. Bannikov S.A., Toshboltaeva M.G. To the Analysis of the Scientific Category “Management System”. Beneficium. 2023;1(46):69–73. https://doi.org/10.34680/BENEFICIUM.2023.1(46).69-73

5. Litvinova V.I. Comparative analysis of methodological approaches in the management system of management. Academia Publica. 2023;9-1:49–52. (In Russian).

6. Korotkov E.M. Research of management systems. 3rd ed., revised and enlarged. Moscow: Yurait; 2023. 226 p. (In Russian).

7. Raevskaya M.A. Efficiency of the enterprise management system. In: Modern issues of science and education: Proceedings of the X International Student Scientific Conference, Moscow, December 1, 2017 – May 21, 2018. Moscow: Euroasian Scientific and Industrial Chamber; 2018. Pp. 75–76. (In Russian).

8. Dikanov M.Yu., Kuvaldina I.S. Methodological approaches to assessing the management system of a modern enterprise. Economy: strategy and practice. 2020;4(15):21–38. (In Russian).

9. Melnikov V.P. Research of management systems. Moscow: Yurait; 2022. 447 p. (In Russian).

10. Khalimon E.A., Sycheva S.M., Shramchenko T.B. Scientific and digital labor organization. In: Correlation interaction of science and practice in the new world: Proceedings of the International Scientific and Practical Conference, St. Petersburg, December 25–26, 2020. 2020. St. Petersburg: St. Petersburg State University of Economics; 2020. Pp. 304–306.

11. Khalimon E.A., Mezina T.V. Homeostasis in the management of socio-economic systems. In: Future of Science – 2022: Proceedings of the 10th International Youth Scientific Conference, Kursk, April 21–22, 2022. Kursk: South-West State University; 2022. Pp. 15–18.

12. Khalimon E.A., Nikitin S.A. Artificial intelligence in organization management. In: Issues of social and economic systems management in modern Russia. Ulyanovsk: Zebra; 2024. Pp. 156–160. (In Russian).